Editing Talk:Lilly's route/@comment-98.224.164.74-20141101144630/@comment-71.11.149.91-20170105082041

Uncharacteristic a bit, and Hisao even knows her nature well enough that it seems very forward for her.  I took it as she was trying to decide still, and wanted to see what what might happen with their relationship.  She was advancing things quickly to let him know, that she was very much in love with him.  You can say you are in love though, but when the tough times come it really can be tested.  I think if Hisao had asked her to stay instead of him just accusing her of having already made her decision about going then she would have stayed.

Think about it.  She has a budding relationship with a guy, a guy that she cares very much about on several levels.  She has confessed to this man and he has reciprocated.  But she also has her family.  Her family that was lost and her sister her was like her mother leaving.  She doesn't know if this guy is worth that.  She doesn't know if he is that committed to her to leave her family.  When he does find out what does he do?  If he asks her to stay, says that he loves her and will be committed to her and will be her new family I can easily see her saying she will stay.  Instead he gets accusatory and angry with her.  I think that while she may have already made her decision it wasn't about going to Scotland.  It was about going to Scotland "unless".  Unless that man that she loves wants her to stay.  ASKS her to stay.  In the good ending he does, he just takes awhile longer to do it.